
Image credit: Unsplash
People use Google to search for criminal defense attorneys under a wide range of diverse circumstances. If someone searches for something like “DUI lawyer near me,” and your firm shows up at the top of local results, you’re more likely to earn a client.
This is why working with the right SEO partner matters so much for a criminal defense practice. The agency you hire will directly impact how easily people find you, and, equally importantly, how legally sound your content is.
Here’s a walkthrough of which questions to ask before you sign anything, along with a rundown of why SEO can be so beneficial for law firms.
Why Is SEO for Criminal Defense Lawyers Unique?
Most legal searches give firms some breathing room in terms of timing and urgency. However, criminal defense-related searches may happen within hours of an arrest or court summons. These are circumstances in which the person searching wants someone they can trust right away.
In this setting, the competition is also steep. You’re up against other local firms, along with national legal directories that might be investing heavily in ranking for terms like “criminal defense attorney” across the US. Good SEO for criminal defense lawyers takes all of this into account.
What Should You Look for in an SEO Service for Criminal Defense Lawyers?
The best SEO service for criminal defense lawyers should function like a direct extension of your firm. They should have extensive industry knowledge, a roster of existing partnerships with lawyers, and a few other key qualities we’ll cover below.
Real Experience in Legal Marketing
Law firm marketing comes with rules and nuances that most industries never deal with. Plus, every state sets its own attorney advertising guidelines, and they may limit claims about past results. The use of words like “specialist” and how testimonials are published may also be limited by state guidelines. An agency with legal experience will protect you from potential issues by carefully reviewing any content published on your behalf before it goes live.
If you are meeting with an SEO firm, ask to see the work they’ve done for other legal professionals in your area. They don’t need to exclusively work with criminal defense attorneys to be qualified to serve you, but they should be comfortable with the details that make legal marketing a unique challenge.
Local-First Search Strategy
Criminal defense searches are highly localized, and it’s far more efficient to compete in the local search landscape than across the country. Your SEO provider should have a clear plan for managing your Google Business Profile, local citations, reviews, and the map results that show up above regular search results in many cases.
Reviews are an especially important focus point here. An SEO agency should never make promises about making critical reviews disappear, but they should be able to provide you with recommendations for constructively responding to those reviews and knowing the difference between a legitimate complaint and spam.
Pages Built Around Specific Charges
A single page for general “Criminal Defense” isn’t enough to get you in front of searchers who need representation for specific charges.
This is why your SEO strategy should include service pages for every common charge you will represent. A solid agency should be able to build these pages by carefully gathering information from the partners at your firm and turning it into engaging content.
A Plan for AI Search
More people than ever now get answers from AI tools and AI-generated search summaries before they click any links. You should always ask how an agency approaches answer engine optimization (AEO) and generative engine optimization (GEO) before you start working with them.
The SEO professional should be able to explain how they structure content so that your firm has a greater chance of getting cited and recommended when someone asks an AI tool for a defense attorney recommendation.
How Can You Tell When an Agency Will Be a Good Partner?
A reliable SEO partner should be clear and honest in their reporting, set your expectations realistically, and give you transparent and detailed answers to any questions you have about their approach. Here’s what to keep an eye out for:
Comprehensive Reporting
A reliable agency will break down your website’s performance as it grows, answering your questions with transparency and candor.
There are plenty of metrics and measurements that are worth seeing as you lean into SEO, including traffic (clicks), impressions (views), and, of course, conversions. A trustworthy SEO partner will walk you through the wins and setbacks in all of these areas and should never inflate numbers or make things seem better than they are.
In addition, a good partner will make earning you more leads, not just building traffic, a key focus of their marketing efforts. This means they will be invested in not just the clicks your pages get, but making sure that the people who visit your site are also making calls, filling out forms, and eventually hiring you to represent them.
Honest Timelines
SEO builds momentum over time. Technical fixes and on-page optimization to your existing website can move the needle early on, but new content added to your site may take several months to gain traction. An agency that promises instant results isn’t one you want to work with.
Clear Answers About Link Building
Backlinks are a big part of any law firm’s SEO success. They signal trust, both to search engines and to searchers. However, an agency should always be transparent about where they source links from, and their focus should be on organically earning them.
Always ask a potential SEO partner about their link-building strategy, including their criteria for linking out to your website. Quality over quantity is the approach you want to see.
Ready To Grow Your Defense Practice?
Our team believes that good SEO starts with a deep understanding of a client. When we work with criminal defense attorneys, we get to know the firm, the market, and the people they serve before we start any further work. From there, we build data-driven strategies that help legal practices get matched with the clients they want to serve.
If you’re ready to talk through your goals, reach out to our team. We’d love to learn about your practice and show you what a focused search strategy could look like for your firm.